Monsters Among Us: Theodore Luckey charged with the murders of Nathan Cashman and David Hanford in the Bedford Country Inn & Suites

Nathan Cashman

Victims
Nathan Cashman, 28
David Hanford, 60

Nathan E. Cashman obituary
Victims identified in double homicide at New Hampshire hotel
Please help us bury our friend, taken too soon.
Bedford hotel remains closed weeks after double murder
One of 2 men killed at New Hampshire hotel is from N.J., authorities say
Ex-Con Charged In Double Homicide Served Time For Terrorizing Elderly Jersey Shore Couple
Man now faces 1st-degree murder charge in NH hotel deaths
Man held without bail after two found dead in Bedford hotel
Man charged in machete murder spent 9 years in prison for tying ex-lover to bed, terrorizing elderly couple
New Details Revealed in Gory Killings at NH Hotel
Man Now Faces 1st-Degree Murder Charge in Hotel Deaths
NJ Man Accused Of Killing 2 In Bedford Hotel Machete Attack
Seaside Heights Man Strangled In NH Hotel; Asbury Man Charged
New Jersey Man Accused of Killing One Victim With Machete in Hotel Lobby and Strangling Another in a Hotel Room

INMATE INFORMATION

THEODORE LEVON LUCKEY
Age 42
Gender Male
Race Black

Date of Birth Oct 28, 1978
Aliases THEODORE LUCKEY
ID Number 65738
Custody Status Date Sep 03, 2021 11:04 AM EDT
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Hillsborough Department of Corrections
Book Date Aug 22, 2021 10:40 AM EDT

LOCATION
Hillsborough Department of Corrections
445 Willow Street
Manchester, NH 03103
(603) 627-5620

Psycho For Love: Armando Barron charged with killing his wife’s lover, Jonathan Amerault, and then forced her, Brittany Barron, to decapitate him after he beat her

Jonathan Amerault

Jonathan L. Amerault obituary
Amerault remembered as ‘outgoing, genuine’ person, passionate hiker
New Hampshire Man Killed Wife’s Lover, Made Her Decapitate Him: Cops
Husband, Wife Arrested In Connection With Murder Of Missing New Hampshire Man
Police: Jaffrey man ordered wife to cut the head off murdered Keene man
NH Woman Accused Of Beheading Lover At Behest Of Husband
AG’s Office: Keene man was murdered; Jaffrey resident charged
Police: N.H. man killed wife’s lover, ordered her to behead him
‘He Just Starts Hitting Him’: Woman Breaks into Tears Testifying Against Husband Who Allegedly Murdered Her Co-Worker Over Snapchat Messages
Woman Allegedly Forced To Decapitate Dead Coworker Takes The Stand At Husband’s Murder Trial

INMATE INFORMATION

ARMANDO R BARRON
Age 30
Gender Male
Race Unknown

Ethnicity Hispanic
Date of Birth Nov 15, 1989
ID Number N18-0372
Custody Status Date Sep 28, 2020 02:56 PM EDT
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Cheshire County Department of Corrections
Book Date Sep 23, 2020 02:09 PM EDT

LOCATION
Cheshire County Department of Corrections

REPORTING AGENCY
Cheshire County Department of Corrections
825 Marlboro Road
Keene, NH 03431
(603) 903-1600

INMATE INFORMATION

BRITANY BARRON
Age 31
Gender Female
Race Unknown

Ethnicity Hispanic
Date of Birth Apr 23, 1989
ID Number N20-0285
Custody Status Date Sep 25, 2020 05:56 PM EDT
Custody Status Out of Custody
Custody Detail Other Law Enforcement Agency
Book Date Sep 25, 2020 01:20 AM EDT

REPORTING AGENCY
Cheshire County Department of Corrections
825 Marlboro Road
Keene, NH 03431
(603) 903-1600

Deadly Girlfriends: Nicole LeBlanc killed ex-boyfriend, Richard Mannion Jr. while he was sleeping in bed; Sentenced to 35 years to life in prison

Richard Mannion Jr.

Richard A. Mannion Jr. obituary
Homicide in Sandown, New Hampshire
Arrest in Connection with the Homicide of Richard Mannion, Jr., in Sandown, New Hampshire
Woman, 38, charged in Sandown murder
Woman charged with first-degree murder of Sandown man
N.H. woman appears in court in Sandown killing
Sandown murder plot unveiled in documents
New Details Revealed In Sandown Homicide
Police: Londonderry woman admitted murder
Londonderry woman pleads guilty to fatally shooting her ex-boyfriend
Londonderry woman gets 35 years to life for ex-boyfriend’s murder
Family seeks tougher sentence for murderer

Movies/Documentaries
Six Degrees of Murder: The Last Shot

INMATE INFORMATION

Robert Cushing murder 6/1/1988 Hampton, NH *Robert McLaughlin Sr convicted of his murder; Sentenced to LWOP*

Robert Cushing

A shock to Hampton as the facts of a murder unfold
Lawyer: McLaughlin was incoherent
McLaughlin’s admissions allowed
Murder Case Confounds System
Policeman’s wife guilty of aiding grudge murder
Forgiving the Unforgivable
State of New Hampshire v Susan McLaughlin Cook 1992 (conviction and sentence affirmed)
Accomplice to Hampton murder asks state for pardon hearing
Excerpt from “Grave Injustice: Unearthing Wrongful Executions

Defendants
Robert McLaughlin Sr – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Susan McLaughlin Cook – convicted as accomplice, sentenced to LWOP

Movies/Documentaries
Motives & Murders: Cracking the Case: A Deadly Obsession

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

Frenemes: Molly Beth Martel killed her best friend, Stephanie Campbell; Sentenced to 20-40 years in prison

Stephanie Campbell

Stephanie L. Campbell obituary
N.H. murder suspect arrested in Napanoch motel
Former star athlete arrested
Manchester woman goes on trial in stabbing death
Former Friend Testifies Against Molly Martel
Jury finds Manchester woman guilty of murdering her friend
Molly Martel gets 20 to 40 years for 2010 murder
Molly Martel sentenced to 20 to 40 years for 2010 killing of Stephanie Campbell
State of New Hampshire v Molly B Martel 2013 (conviction and sentence affirmed)

Movies/Documentaries
Deadly Women: Friends to Foes

INMATE INFORMATION

NAME MOLLY BETH MARTEL
AGE 28
INMATE ID 90563
TERM ID 62410
BOOKED DATE 02/02/2012
MAXED 10/24/2050
FACILITY NH State Prison for Women

CaseID 131199
Offense Date 11/2/2010
Minimum 10/29/2030
Maximum 10/24/2050
Docket 216-2010-CR-02628
Court HILLSBOROUGH SUPERIOR COURT NORTH

Monsters Among Us: John Alan Brooks hired 4 others to help him kill Jack Reid Sr. over some motorcycles

Jack Reid Sr.

Jack Reid Sr obituary
Agreement requires him to testify in N.H. death penalty case
Knight murder-for-hire trial begins
Lawyer: Knight ‘participated fully’ in murder
Witness details alleged murder-for-hire plot
Knight sentenced to life without parole for murder of Derry man
Witness testifies millionaire grateful he killed handyman
Millionaire Convicted In Handyman’s Murder
Millionaire Brooks guilty in murder for hire
Victim’s family confronts his killer in N.H. court
John Brooks Sentenced to LWOP in 2003 New Hampshire for Murder
NH court upholds conviction in handyman’s death
State of New Hampshire v Robin Knight 2011 (conviction and sentence affirmed)
Two more sentenced for Reid murder
Man imprisoned for murder for hire
Mother says she has proof son did not plot NH murder
New Evidence in NH Murder-for-hire Case
Murder-for-hire accomplice from North Hampton loses bid for new trial
Jail chief: Murder conspirator Jesse Brooks used mom to pay inmates

Movies/Documentaries
Six Degrees of Murder: Dear Dad

Defendants
John Alan Brooks – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Robin Knight – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Michael Benton – pled guilty, sentenced to 33 years to life in prison
Joseph Vrooman – pled guilty, sentenced to 17 1/2 – 30 years in prison
Jesse Brooks – convicted, sentenced to 15-30 years in prison

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

Cold Case: Arthur Collins shot and killed George Jodoin; Sentenced to 30 years in prison

George Jodoin

Arrest Made in Cold Case Murder From 2001 in Auburn, New Hampshire
Arrest made in 2001 cold case slaying
Arrest Made In NH Cold Case
Man charged in 2001 Auburn murder declared competent to stand trial
Justice served for family of George Jodoin
Police: Man admits to killing Manchester pawn shop owner
Man sentenced to 30 years after plea in cold-case killing
Manchester man gets life for 2001 murder

Movies/Documentaries
Murder Comes To Town: The Nightmare After Christimas

INMATE INFORMATION

NAME: ARTHUR DELBERT COLLINS
AGE: 47
INMATE ID: 77836
TERM ID: 46509
BOOKED DATE: 04/27/2007
MAXED: 4/21/2111
FACILITY: NH State Prison for Men
CASEID: 162554
Offense Date” 12/26/2001
Minimum: 5/7/2042
Maximum: 4/21/2111
Docket: 218-2012-CR-00648
Court: ROCKINGHAM SUPERIOR COURT

Psycho For Love: James Robarge killed his wife, Kelly when she filed for divorce; Sentenced to 30 years to life in prison

Kelly Robarge

James Robarge has been charged with killing his wife, Kelly Robarge. They believe she was killed the same day that James Robarge received his divorce papers. They had been married for over 20 years, but had been living apart for a few months, so this should not have surprised him. It appears to not be a good situation. Police found blood splatters in their home, and drag marks outside. James Robarge was arrested after a chase in Vermont. He is fighting extradition, so it may be a while before he is in NH to face these charges.

Update: James Robarge was convicted of her murder. He was sentenced to 30 years in prison.

Body Found in New Hampshire Woods Believed to be Kelly Robarge
Woman’s Body Found In Unity
Body positively identified as missing NH woman, Kelly Robarge
Husband to be charged with murder of Charlestown woman fights extradition from Vt.
Husband of murdered Charlestown woman to be charged in her death
Court records: Blood evidence found at home of slain woman
Arrest Warrant Issued for James Robarge in Connection With the Homicide of His Wife Kelly Robarge
Daughter at trial: If dad couldn’t have mom, nobody could
Jury: Husband guilty of killing, dumping wife’s body
James Robarge gets at least 30 years in wife’s beating death

Movies/Documentaries
Bad Blood: Daughters Divided

INMATE INFORMATION

NAME: JAMES RICHARD ROBARGE
AGE: 46
INMATE ID: 94796
TERM ID: 74243
BOOKED DATE: 01/01/1900
MAXED: 7/5/2112
FACILITY: Northern NH Correctional Facility
CaseID: 162534
OffenseDate: 6/27/2013
Minimum: 7/22/2043
Maximum: 7/5/2112
Docket: 220-2013-CR-00120
Court: SULLIVAN SUPERIOR COURT

Monsters Among Us: Seth Mazzaglia killed Elizabeth “Lizzi” Marriott after she turned down his sexual advances; Sentenced to LWOP

Elizabeth “Lizzi” Marriott

UNH Remembers Murdered Student Elizabeth Marriott At Vigil
Missing UNH Student Lizzi Marriott Dead; Man Arrested
Suspect charged in death of missing New Hampshire student
29-Year-Old Karate Instructor Charged In Murder Of UNH Student
Dover man charged with murder in death of missing UNH student Elizabeth Marriott
Trial To Begin This Week In 2012 Slaying Of UNH Student From Westboro
Jury To Tour Lizzi Marriott Murder Scene In New Hampshire
Witness says she saw boyfriend raping murder victim
Woman: Boyfriend raped, killed Lizzi Marriott
Slain UNH student Lizzi Marriott of Westborough twice rebuffed murder suspect’s advances, former girlfriend testifies
Defense Witness: Mazzaglia Girlfriend Said She Killed UNH Student By Accident
Defense Rests In UNH Student Murder Trial
No parole for woman involved in Marriott murder
Lizzi Marriott’s Family Rips Seth Mazzaglia At Murder Sentencing
Slain teen’s parents describe grief as killer sentenced to life
Man gets life for killing New Hampshire coed “Lizzi” Marriott
NH Supreme Court hears Seth Mazzaglia’s appeal

Books
cDark Heart: A True Story of Sex, Manipulation, and Murder
Movies/Documentaries
Deadly Sins: If I Can’t Have You…

Defendants
Seth Mazzaglia – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Kathryn McDonough – pled guilty, sentenced to 3 years in prison with no parole

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

Monsters Among Us: John Edward Brewer killed at least 2 women, probably at least 2 more

Victims
Michele LaFond, 23 [NH 3/4/1987] (no picture)
Dina Kichler, 21 [12/1990]
Laura Kempton, 23 [9/28/1981] [suspected victim]
Tammy Little, 20 [10/19/1982] [suspected victim]

Find-A-Grave: Michele Lambert Lafond
Find-A-Grave: Dina Fay Ward Kichler

Man charged in murder freed to await his trial
Man held for 2 years released to await trial
Brewer in jail again
Jacksonville man charged in N.H.
Florida man arraigned in 1987 New Hampshire death
Killer confesses to murders in Florida, New Hampshire
Suspect apparently ready to plead in LaFond murder case
Man ready to plead guilty in 1987 N.H. murder case
Man freed in ’94 gets life term
Navy Wife Dina Kichler Raped & Murdered in Florida; John Brewer Plead Guilty to Avoid Death Penalty, Sentenced to Life in Prison (December 3, 1990)
Dublin suspect may be linked to three other murders
Cold Case: Laura Kempton
New England Cold Cases: John Edward Brewer
New Hampshire unsolved case file: Who killed Laura Kempton?
Unsolved Homicides: Tammy Little and Laura Kempton

Movies/Documentaries
Unusual Suspects: An Eye for Murder
In Ice Cold Blood: Three Hairs

INMATE INFORMATION

DC Number: 280085
Name: BREWER, JOHN E
Race: WHITE
Sex: MALE
Hair Color: BROWN
Eye Color: HAZEL
Height: 5’09”
Weight: 152 lbs.
Birth Date: 05/30/1958
Initial Receipt Date: 08/03/1999
Current Facility: UNION C.I.
Current Custody: CLOSE
Current Release Date: SENTENCED TO LIFE

Aliases:
JOHN BREWER
JOHN E BREWER
JOHN EDWARD BREWER

Scars, Marks, and Tattoos:
Type Location Description
TATTOO BACK MUSHROOM MANDY
TATTOO LEFT ARM REAPER YOSMITE SAM
TATTOO LEFT CHEST BIRD DARLENE
TATTOO RIGHT ARM TAZ FLAG
TATTOO RIGHT CHEST HEART