Monsters Among Us: Dustin Jaye killed Debra Striano because he believed she had thousands of dollars in her home; He was sentenced to LWOP

Debra Striano
Debra Striano

San Carlos Park homicide victim identified
Report: Physical evidence ties men to Three Oaks murder
Murder suspect’s family talking to Fox 4
Horrifying 911 call released
Three Oaks murder suspect shot dead after second killing
Law enforcement kills fugitive in North Fort Myers following second homicide
Dustin Jaye guilty of murdering Debra Striano
Dustin Jaye gets life in prison for San Carlos murder
Three Oaks Murder case to be featured on Deadly Sins series
Gregory F. Imhoff murder 8/07/2012 North Fort Myers, FL *Suspect, Billy Ray Retherford, was shot and killed in a shootout with law enforcement*

Movies/Documentaries
Deadly Sins: Sunshine State of Delirium

Defendants
Dustin Jaye – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Billy Ray Retherford – killed in a shootout with the police

INMATE INFORMATION

DC Number: B05425
Name: JAYE, DUSTIN D
Race: WHITE
Sex: MALE
Hair Color: BLACK
Eye Color: BROWN
Height: 5’08”
Weight: 141 lbs.
Birth Date: 11/10/1988
Initial Receipt Date: 06/05/2014
Current Facility: CALHOUN C.I.
Current Custody: CLOSE
Current Release Date: SENTENCED TO LIFE

Aliases:
DUSTIN JAYE
DUSTIN D JAYE
DUSTIN D. JAYE
DUSTIN DEAN JAYE

Scars, Marks, and Tattoos:
Type Location Description
TATTOO BACK CRIST CRYING
TATTOO BACK JESUS
TATTOO LEFT ARM FAST MONEY , PICTURE OF MONEY
TATTOO OTHER EAGLE,KEY HOLE,FACE ON CHEST
TATTOO OTHER ONLY THE STRONG SURVIVE,ON CHEST
TATTOO RIGHT ARM G S UP/MAN/HOLE DOWN/NAKED LADY

Current Prison Sentence History:
Offense Date Offense Sentence Date County Case No. Prison Sentence Length
07/24/2012 1ST DG MUR/PREMED. OR ATT. 05/19/2014 LEE 1217514 SENTENCED TO LIFE
07/24/2012 BURGLARY,ARMED W/EXP. OR WEAPO 05/19/2014 LEE 1217514 SENTENCED TO LIFE
07/24/2012 TORTURES ANIMAL W/INTENT INFLI 05/19/2014 LEE 1217514 5Y 0M 0D

Note: The offense descriptions are truncated and do not necessarily reflect the crime of conviction. Please refer to the court documents or the Florida Statutes for further information or definition.

Incarceration History:
Date In-Custody Date Out-of-Custody
03/06/2008 02/17/2009
09/24/2009 09/22/2011
11/03/2011 03/17/2012
06/05/2014 Currently Incarcerated

Prior Prison History: (Note: Data reflected covers periods of incarceration with the Florida Dept.of Corrections since January of 1983)
Offense Date Offense Sentence Date County Case No. Prison Sentence Length
07/17/2007 BURG/DWELL/OCCUP.CONVEY 02/25/2008 LEE 0718499 1Y 6M 27D
07/17/2007 GRAND THEFT,300 L/5,000 02/25/2008 LEE 0718499 1Y 6M 27D
07/17/2007 BURG/DWELL/OCCUP.CONVEY 06/15/2009 LEE 0718499 2Y 10M 15D
07/17/2007 GRAND THEFT,300 L/5,000 06/15/2009 LEE 0718499 2Y 10M 15D
03/28/2009 FELONY BATTERY 09/08/2009 LEE 0915850 2Y 11M 0D

Kathryn Bishop murder 3/4/1993 Hummelstown, PA *Timothy Patrick McEnany convicted, sentenced to life in prison

remembering the victimsFrom Timothy McEnany appeal: On March 4, 1993, at 12:45 a.m., eighty-two year old Kathryn Bishop was found dead on the floor of her residence. Wayne K. Ross, a forensic pathologist, determined that Mrs. Bishop had been stomped to death sometime between 9:00 p.m. and 11:30 p.m. on March 3, 1993. Paint chips were found on Mrs. Bishop’s hands, and black t-shirt fibers were on her face, neck and clothing. Additionally, Mrs. Bishop’s kitchen door window had been smashed, her basement window had been opened and scuff marks were left on her clothes dryer which was located just below the basement window.

Subsequent investigation revealed that the appellant, Timothy McEnany, and his cousin, Andrew Reischman, were at Mrs. Bishop’s residence to clean her chimney between the hours of 2:00 p.m. and 5:00 p.m. on March 3, 1993. While appellant and Reischman were cleaning the chimney, Mrs. Bishop and her daughter, Janet Seitz, were discussing Mrs. Bishop’s finances. At this time, one of the workers was in the house. There was a large roll of paper money and a basket full of change owned by Mrs. Bishop in plain view. Mrs. Seitz and her husband left Mrs. Bishop at approximately 5:00 p.m. At that time, appellant and Reischman were still present at the house.

During the time period between March 4, 1993 and March 7, 1993, Trooper Jeffrey Stansfield spoke with appellant regarding his contact with Mrs. Bishop on March 3, 1993. Appellant told Trooper Stansfield that he had been to Mrs. Bishop’s residence on March 3, 1993 to clean her chimney. Appellant also stated that he was at a bar called Shane’s Flight Deck between the hours of 6:30 p.m. and 1:30 a.m. on the evening of *615 the murder. The bar is located about fifteen (15) miles from Mrs. Bishop’s residence and over sixty (60) miles from appellant’s home. A cook from Shane’s saw appellant at the bar around 6:00 p.m. that evening, but not after that time. A bartender from Shane’s testified that she saw appellant after midnight that evening and that he was acting in a manner to ensure that his presence was noticed.

Officers then spoke with Mrs. Bishop’s neighbor, Dawn Rogers, who stated that she heard the sound of breaking glass between the hours of 10:00 and 10:30 p.m. on March 3, 1993. A couple of minutes later, Mrs. Rogers saw a person running down the street from the direction of Mrs. Bishop’s house, carrying a clear bag containing a large envelope. Mrs. Rogers’ description of this person matched the general description of Reischman.

Chimney sweep charged in slaying
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v Timothy P. McEnany 1995
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania v Timothy P. McEnany 1999 (affirmed)
Timothy McEnany v DiGuglielmo 2007 (habeas corpus denied)

Movies/Documentaries
Forensic Files: A Case of the Flue

INMATE INFORMATION

Timothy McEnany

TIMOTHY PATRICK MCENANY
Age: 48
Sex: MALE
Date of Birth: 10/03/1966
Citizenship: USA
Race: WHITE
Complexion: LIGHT
Height: 5′ 08″
Current Location: SOMERSET
Permanent Location: SOMERSET
Committing County: DAUPHIN

Alternate ID’s
Booking Number#: CP0502
DOC/PBPP OID#: CP0502
Other Jail Numbers#: CP0502
Statewide Id#: 20872021
Statewide Id#: 20872021
Aliases
MCEWANY, TIMOTHY PATRICK

Update: David Marsh murder *Alexis Alan Garcia arrested, another suspect still at large*

David Marsh
David Marsh

News Archive: David Marsh
Police arrest man in Lee Mart shooting death
Murray police make arrest in fatal convenience store shooting
Man arrested in connection with fatal Lee Mart shooting
Murray police arrest one of two suspects in fatal Lee Mart holdup
Police arrest man in Murray convenience store shooting death

INMATE INFORMATION

Alexis Garcia

Name: ALEXIS ALAN GARCIA
Sex: M
Age: 20
Height: 508
Weight: 130
Race: WHITE
Hair Color: BLACK
Eye Color: BROWN

Inmate Information
Booking #: 15021110
SO#: 366244
State ID: 1291889
FBI: 592874EH1
Citizen: UNITED STATES
COB: MEXICO

Incarceration Information
Current Location: MAIN
County: SALT LAKE
Current Housing Section: 02
Current Housing Block: C
Current Housing Cell: 18
Current Housing Bed: B
Booked Date: 04/14/2015
Release Date:

Alias Information
ALEXIS VICIOUS

charges Alexis Garcia

News Archive: David Marsh

David Marsh
David Marsh

David Marsh murder 3/23/2015 Murray, UT *Lee Mart convenience store clerk for 25 years found shot after a robbery; David died 3/23/2015*
Update: David Marsh murder *Alexis Alan Garcia arrested, another suspect still at large*

Fort Worth Valero store robbery-murder: Kwame Rockwell convicted of Daniel Rojas; sentenced to death

Daniel Rojas and Jerry Burnett

Victims
Daniel Rojas-Torres
Jerry Burnett

4 charged with capital murder in robbery
Families tell killer what he took from them
Sentencing phase of Fort Worth capital murder trial goes to the jury
Jury sends out notes seeking clarification, second look at evidence in Rockwell capital murder case
Convenience store killer sentenced to death in Fort Worth
Kwame Rockwell Gets Death for Gas Station Murders
Convenience Store Armed Robbery Trial Starts This Week
Randy Seibel murder trial under way in Fort Worth
Third suspect in 2010 gas station robbery, murder sentenced to life in prison
Fort Worth man sentenced to life without parole for robbery that left two dead
State of Texas v Tywro Pierre Thomas 2013 (Court’s charge for jury)
Kwame A. Rockwell v State of Texas 2013 (affirmed conviction and sentence)
Death Penalty Upheld In Fort Worth Slaying
Kwame A. Rockwell – Texas Death Row

Defendants
Kwame Rockwell – convicted of Daniel Rojas murder; sentenced to death
Chance Smith – pled guilty to robbery; sentenced to 20 years in prison in exchange for testifying
Randy Keith Seibel – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Tywron Pierre Thomas – convicted, sentenced to LWOP
Timothy Vashaun Thomas – convicted, sentenced to 15 years in prison

INMATE INFORMATION

Kwame Rockwell

SID Number: 05562120
TDCJ Number: 00999570
Name: ROCKWELL,KWAME A
Race: B
Gender: M
DOB: 1975-12-07
Maximum Sentence Date: DEATH ROW
Current Facility: JESTER IV
Projected Release Date: DEATH ROW
Parole Eligibility Date: DEATH ROW

Offense History
Offense Date: 2010-03-23
Offense: CAPITAL MURDER(DEATH)
Sentence Date: 2011-01-08
County: TARRANT
Case No.: 1195088D
Sentence (YY-MM-DD): 88-88-8888

INMATE INFORMATION

SID Number: 07953381
TDCJ Number: 01733874
Name: SMITH, CHANCE MCKENZIE
Race: W
Gender: M
DOB: 1986-11-25
Maximum Sentence Date: 2030-03-26
Current Facility: LUTHER
Projected Release Date: 2030-03-26
Parole Eligibility Date: 2020-03-25

Offense History
Offense Date: 2010-03-23
Offense: AGG ROBBERY W/DWPN FIREARM (2X)
Sentence Date: 2011-08-12
County: TARRANT
Case No.: 1195100D, 1195973D
Sentence (YY-MM-DD): 20-00-00

INMATE INFORMATION

Randy Keith Seibel

SID Number: 07072079
TDCJ Number: 01825390
Name: SEIBEL, RANDY KEITH
Race: W
Gender: M
DOB: 1974-05-24
Maximum Sentence Date: LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE
Current Facility: BILL CLEMENTS
Projected Release Date: LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE
Parole Eligibility Date: LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE

Offense History
Offense Date: 2010-03-23
Offense: CAPITAL MURDER
Sentence Date: 2012-12-10
County: TARRANT
Case No.: 1195090D
Sentence (YY-MM-DD): 55-55-5555

INMATE INFORMATION

Tyrone Pierre Thomas

SID Number: 07037043
TDCJ Number: 01898455
Name: THOMAS,TYWRON PIERRE
Race: B
Gender: M
DOB: 1986-05-23
Maximum Sentence Date: LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE
Current Facility: ALLRED
Projected Release Date: LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE
Parole Eligibility Date: LIFE WITHOUT PAROLE

INMATE INFORMATION

SID Number: 08672745
TDCJ Number: 01922259
Name: THOMAS,TIMOTHY VASHAUN
Race: B
Gender: M
DOB: 1988-03-04 Maximum Sentence Date: 2025-09-01
Current Facility: TULIA
Projected Release Date: 2025-09-01
Parole Eligibility Date: 2018-03-03
Next Parole Review Date: 03/03/2018

Offense History
Offense Date: 2010-03-23
Offense: AGG ROBBERY W/DWPN
Sentence Date: 2014-03-21
County: TARRANT
Case No.: 1212502D
Sentence (YY-MM-DD): 15-00-00

David Marsh murder 3/23/2015 Murray, UT *Lee Mart convenience store clerk for 25 years found shot after a robbery; David died 3/23/2015*

David Marsh
David Marsh

Murray convenience store clerk found shot behind counter
Clerk found shot in Murray convenience store; police search for asssailants
Community rallies around clerk shot during robbery; crime was caught on camera
Well-loved store clerk shot in Murray, suspects escape
Clerk shot during Murray robbery improves; suspects remain at large
Now, it’s murder: Murray police confirm store clerk has died
Friends, customers mourn clerk who died from gunshot wound
Victim of Lee Mart shooting passes away
News Archive: David Marsh

Lee Mart robbery

Lauren Kiefer murder 12/25/2007 DuPage County, IL *Robert Rejda committed suicide in his jail cell before he could plead guilty*

Lauren Kiefer
Lauren Kiefer

Remember Lauren
Lauren M. Kiefer obituary
Lauren Kiefer’s mother keeps daughter’s memory alive 6 years after murder
Willowbrook 5K memorializes Lauren Kiefer
Christmas Day slaying is ruled a homicide
Charges Filed in Christmas Day Murder Investigation
Man, 25, indicted in Christmas slaying
Accused Murderer Robert Rejda Found Dead in Cell
Man accused of Christmas Day murder found dead in jail

Robert Rejda
Robert Rejda

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 3,457 other followers

%d bloggers like this: