News Archives: Rhoden Family Murders

Victims
Christopher Rhoden, 40
Dana Lynn Rhoden, 37
Kenneth Rhoden, 44
Gary Rhoden, 38
Clarence “Frankie” Rhoden, 20
Hannah “Hazel” Gilley, 20
Hanna May Rhoden, 19
Christopher Rhoden Jr., 16

Pike County Massacre: Eight members of the Rhoden Family were murdered while they slept; Four members of the Wagner Family have been charged
Update: Rhoden Family murders *Four members of the Wagner Family were arrested and charged for the murders; Trials starting*

Podcasts
The Piketon Massacre (several episodes)
3 Sisters in Crime: The Rhoden Family

Movies/Documentaries
The Piketon Family Murders

Defendants
George “Billy” Wagner III
Angela Wagner – pled guilty,
George Wagner IV -trial starting end of August
Edward “Jake” Wagner – pled guilty, agreed to testify against family members, sentenced to 8 consecutive LWOP sentences

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

Advertisement

Update: Rhoden Family murders *Four members of the Wagner Family were arrested and charged for the murders; Trials starting*

Victims
Christopher Rhoden, 40
Dana Lynn Rhoden, 37
Kenneth Rhoden, 44
Gary Rhoden, 38
Clarence “Frankie” Rhoden, 20
Hannah “Hazel” Gilley, 20
Hanna May Rhoden, 19
Christopher Rhoden Jr., 16

News Archives: Rhoden Family Murders
George ‘Billy’ Wagner, suspect in Ohio family murders, appears in court
Mass Murder of Rhoden Family Reportedly Happened Months After a Suspect and Victim Broke Up
Edward ‘Jake’ Wagner pleads guilty in fatal shootings of Rhoden family
Jake Wagner Admits His Family Killed Eight Members of the Rhoden and Gilley Families in Ohio’s 2016 Pike County Massacre
Angela Wagner pleads guilty in connection with Rhoden family murders
Second Wagner Family Member, a Grandmother, Pleads Guilty in Pike County Massacre That Left 8 Dead
Pike County Massacre articles
Pike County Massacre Suspect Seeks Dismissal of Murder Charges and Death Penalty Case, Says Prosecutors Know He Didn’t Kill Anyone
Judge rules death penalty still on the table for George Wagner III despite family member’s plea agreement with prosecutors
Judge keeps death penalty chance for George Wagner IV charged in Rhoden family murder
Jury selection begins for George Wagner IV’s trial in Pike County
Pike County Massacre: First murder trial begins Monday
Ohio Jurors Will See Where Pike County Massacre Took Place as First Member of the Wagner Family Stands Trial
Which Locations Will The Jury Visit Ahead Of The Pike County Family Massacre Trial?

Podcasts
The Piketon Massacre (several episodes)
3 Sisters in Crime: The Rhoden Family

Movies/Documentaries
The Piketon Family Murders

Defendants
George “Billy” Wagner III
Angela Wagner – pled guilty,
George Wagner IV -trial starting end of August
Edward “Jake” Wagner – pled guilty, agreed to testify against family members, sentenced to 8 consecutive LWOP sentences

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

Monsters Among Us: Erick Almandinger, along with 3 teenagers, kidnapped and killed his friend, David Grunwald


David Grunwald

Find-A-Grave: David Benjamin Grunwald
Facebook: Justice for David Grunwald, Palmer, Alaska
‘No clue’: Family of teen charged in Grunwald killing say they share public’s shock
First defendant sentenced in Palmer teen’s 2016 murder gets 45 years during emotional live-streamed hearing
Alaska man gets 99 years in execution-style killing of teen
Palmer man found guilty of murder in Fairbanks court
Defendant who helped troopers find body gets 99 years in prison for Mat-Su teen’s 2016 murder
Jury delivers guilty verdicts on all counts for first teen to face trial in Grunwald slaying
Almandinger sentenced to 99 years for murder of David Grunwald
‘I killed my friend’: Palmer resident sentenced to serve 99 years for 2016 murder of Mat-Su teen
‘Ringleader’ Sentenced to 99 Years in Prison for Murdering Friend with Help of 3 Other Teenage Boys
22-year-old Alaska man gets nearly 100 years for killing 16-year-old classmate in 2016
Last and youngest defendant in 2016 murder of Mat-Su teen sentenced to 75 years in prison
Bradley Renfro sentenced
Bradley Renfro sentenced to 105 years in Grunwald murder

Defendants
Erick Almandinger – convicted, sentenced to 99 years in prison
Dominic Johnson – convicted, sentenced to 99 years in prison
Austin Barrett – pled guilty, sentenced to 45 years in prison
Bradley Renfro – convicted, sentenced to 105 years in prison
Devin Peterson – pled guilty (accessory), sentenced to 6 years in prison

INMATE INFORMATION

ERICK M ALMANDI
Age 22
Gender Male
Race White

Ethnicity Non-Hispanic
ID Number 735350
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Mat-Su Pretrial

LOCATION
Mat-Su Pretrial
339 E. Dogwood Ave.
Palmer, AK 99645
(907) 745-0943

INMATE INFORMATION

DOMINIC JOHNSON

Age 22
Gender Male
Race White

Ethnicity Non-Hispanic
ID Number 735615
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Goose Creek Correctional Center

LOCATION
Goose Creek Correctional Center
22301 West Alsop Road
Wasilla, AK 99654
(907) 864-8100

INMATE INFORMATION

AUSTIN B BARRETT

Age 25
Gender Male
Race White

Ethnicity Non-Hispanic
ID Number 726270
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Wildwood Correctional Center
Scheduled Release Dec 08, 2046 12:00 AM AKST

LOCATION
Wildwood Correctional Center
10 Chugach Ave.
Kenai, AK 99611
(907) 260-7200

INMATE INFORMATION

BRADLEY J RENFRO
Age 21
Gender Male
Race White

Ethnicity Non-Hispanic
ID Number 735620
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Goose Creek Correctional Center

LOCATION
Goose Creek Correctional Center
22301 West Alsop Road
Wasilla, AK 99654
(907) 864-8100

INMATE INFORMATION

Name: DEVIN LEE PETERSON
Register Number: 19906-006
Age: 24
Race: Black
Sex: Male
Release Date: 08/18/2023
Located At: FCI Herlong
(He is in federal custody)

Mothers From Hell: Heather Reynolds killed her 17-month-old son, Axel Jayce, allegedly because he got in the way of her extramarital affair; Sentencing will be in October


Axel Jayce Reynolds

Find-A-Grave: Axel Jayce Reynolds
Mom Of Toddler Found Dead At South Jersey Home Charged With His Murder
Prosecutors: NJ mom suffocated toddler son because he was getting in way of extramarital affair
New Jersey mother accused of killing toddler faces new charges in murder-for-hire plot
Mother Killed 17-Month-Old Son Because She Felt He Was Getting In Way Of Her Affair, Prosecutors Say
New Jersey mother accused of killing toddler faces new charges in murder-for-hire plot
Jury convicts Heather Reynolds of murder in death of her 17-month-old son
NJ Woman Convicted of Murder in Death of 17-Month-Old Son
Camden County woman convicted of killing her 17-month-old son and acquitted of plotting to kill her ex-boyfriend
N.J. mom convicted of killing 17-month-old son by suffocating him with cleaning wipe
N.J. Mom Convicted of Murdering Toddler Because He Was ‘Obstacle’ to Her Extramarital Affair
Sicklerville woman convicted of murder in death of 17-month-old son
N.J. Mom Convicted of Murdering 1-Year-Old Son She Viewed as ‘Obstacle to Her Relationship with Her Boyfriend’
Mom convicted of suffocating 17-month old to death with cleaning wipe

Defendants
Heather Reynolds – convicted,
Jeffrey Callahan

INMATE INFORMATION

HEATHER REYNOLDS
Age 44
Gender Female
Race White

Ethnicity Unknown
Date of Birth Nov 13, 1977
ID Number 17268
Custody Status Date Jun 14, 2019 12:56 AM EDT
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Camden County Jail
Book Date Jun 14, 2019 12:45 AM EDT

LOCATION
Camden County Jail
600 Market Street
Camden, NJ 08101
(609) 299-1694

INMATE INFORMATION

JEFFREY A CALLAHAN

Age 45
Gender Male
Race White

Ethnicity Unknown
Date of Birth Aug 05, 1976
ID Number 400006162
Custody Status Date May 18, 2021 03:03 PM EDT
Custody Status In Custody
Custody Detail Camden County Jail
Book Date May 18, 2021 02:52 PM EDT

LOCATION
Camden County Jail
600 Market Street
Camden, NJ 08101
(609) 299-1694

Deadly Wives: Brenda Kay McCutcheon shot and killed her husband, Dr. Frank “Buddy” McCutcheon Jr while he was sleeping


Dr. Frank “Buddy” McCutcheon Jr

Dr. Frank McCutcheon, Jr. obituary
Find-A-Grave: Dr Frank “Buddy” McCutcheon Jr.
Memorial for slain doctor held at University of Arkansas
Wife Wanted In Shooting Death Of Husband With Fayetteville Ties
North Carolina woman wanted for murder of her husband now living in Tipton County
Year later, wife charged in plastic surgeon’s death
Wife of Arden plastic surgeon indicted for his murder
On anniversary of NC plastic surgeon’s death, cold case remains a mystery
Mid-South native wanted for killing husband turned herself in
NC doctor killed amid embezzlement investigation
Brenda McCutcheon found guilty in husband’s murder
State of North Carolina v Brenda Kay McCutcheon 2021 (conviction and sentence affirmed)
Appeal denied for Arden woman sentenced to life in prison for 2016 murder of husband
Dateline NBC features Asheville’s Dr. Buddy McCutcheon murder with ‘unseen footage’

Movies/Documentaries
Dateline: The Day the Music Died

INMATE INFORMATION

Monsters Among Us: Jacky Cardale Mayfield killed MeShawna Jones and Markey Goff to death while they were sitting in an SUV in Chamberlain Park; Sentenced to life in prison

Victims
MeShawna Jones, 32
Markey Goff, 26

Find-A-Grave: MeShawna Latrice “Mesha” Jones
Facebook: Meshawna Jones
Find-A-Grave: Markey Gaymar Goff
Facebook: Markey Goff
Detectives make arrest in double homicide at Chamberlain Park
Bodies found near Henryetta ID’d
Two Found Shot To Death In SUV At Tulsa’s Chamberlain Park
Man charged in connection to double homicide at Chamberlain Park in north Tulsa
Person of interest in Chamberlain Park double homicide in custody
Police Make Arrest In Chamberlain Park Double Murder
Man Charged In Chamberlain Park Double Murder
Tulsa Woman Pleads Guilty To Helping In Double Murder

Defendants
Jacky Cardale Mayfield – convicted, sentenced to life in prison
Rebecca Williams – pled guilty, sentenced to 10 years in prison (accessory after the fact)

Movies/Documentaries
The First 48: Stolen Innocence

INMATE INFORMATION

INMATE INFORMATION

Monsters Among Us: Jeremy Arrington killed 3 people during a home invasion, because he was mad about a Facebook post about him; Sentenced to 375 years in prison

Victims
Syasia McBurroughs, 23
Ariel Whitehurst, 7
Al-Jahon Whitehurst, 11

Find-A-Grave: Syasia McBurroughs
Ariel Little Whitehurst obituary
Find-A-Grave: Ariel White Whitehurst
Al-Jahon Whitehurst obituary
Find-A-Grave: Al-Jahon Whitehurst
2 children, woman stabbed to death in Newark identified
Police arrest Jeremy Arrington in connection with fatal Newark stabbings
Man pleads not guilty in fatal Newark stabbings of woman, 2 kids
Four years after 3 killed in home invasion, family still mourns as COVID delays trial
N.J. Man Convicted of Breaking into Home, Murdering 2 Kids and Woman over Facebook Post
Jury: Man guilty of Newark murders of 2 children, woman in armed home invasion
Man Convicted in Newark Bloodbath That Left 3 Dead, Including 2 Children
NJ man convicted of brutal murder of 2 children, college student over Facebook post
Newark ‘House of Horrors’ Killer Gets 3 Life Sentences for Slaying of Woman, 2 Kids
N.J. man gets 375 years for brutal 2016 murders of 2 children, college student in Newark
New Jersey Man Convicted Of Three Murders, Three Attempted Murders Over Facebook Comment
N.J. Man Sentenced to 375 Years in Prison After Facebook Post Led to ‘House of Horrors’ Torture and Murders that Left Three Dead
N.J. man convicted of torturing and killing college student and 2 kids over Facebook comment

INMATE INFORMATION

Serial Killer: Khalil Wheeler-Weaver – killed at least 4 young women; Sentenced to 160+ years in prison

Victims
Robin Daphne Michele West, 19 [9/13/2016 Orange, NJ]
Joanne Brown, 33 [10/2016 Orange, NJ]
Tiffany Taylor (survived) (no picture)
Sarah Butler, 20 [11/23/2016 West Orange, NJ]
Mawa Doumbia, 15 [10/7/2016 Newark, NJ]

Find-A-Grave: Robin West
Find-A-Grave: Joanna Brown
Missing Montclair, N.J. Woman Found Dead At Eagle Rock Reservation
Suspect Charged In Montclair Woman’s Death Accused Of Killing 2nd Woman
NJ Man Accused Of Killing Two Women Charged With Additional Murder, Assault
Slain Montclair college student mourned at funeral
Death Of Missing Montclair Woman Sarah Butler Ruled Homicide
New Jersey Serial Killer Khalil Wheeler-Weaver Convicted Of Murdering 3 Women, Attempting To Kill 4th Victim
Convicted serial killer, rapist says cops got the wrong guy before judge sentences him to 160 years in prison
Serial killer who murdered Montclair 20-year-old sentenced to 160 years
Serial killer lured on social media by a friend of a victim gets 160 years
Judge sentences serial killer who lured women on dating app to 160 years in prison: ‘Absolutely lacks remorse’
N.J. Serial Killer Gets 160 Years in Prison for Using Social Media to Target Victims of 2016 Rapes and Murders
Orange Man Charged with Murder of Missing 15 year old girl
Convicted NJ serial killer who murdered three now charged in killing of fourth, a teenager
Convicted New Jersey Serial Killer Charged In Murder Of Teen Who Disappeared In 2016
New Jersey Serial Killer Charged in Teenager’s 2016 Murder
Convicted Serial Killer Facing New Charges in Strangling Death of New Jersey Teen
Convicted serial killer Khalil Wheeler-Weaver charged in murder of missing Newark teenager Mawa Doumbia
Wikipedia: Khalil Wheeler-Weaver

INMATE INFORMATION

Inmate Murder: Julio Cesar Garza charged with the murder of inmate Carlos-Adrian Javier Hernandez, who killed Keely Amber Hall; Sentenced to LWOP


Carlos-Adrian Javier Hernandez

Inmate charged with murder of cellmate, who was serving time for teen’s rape, death
Inmate charged with murder of cellmate, who was serving time for teen’s rape, death
Death penalty sought for Julio Garza
Life without parole ordered for Utah inmate who brutally killed cellmate

INMATE INFORMATION

Offender Number: 198032
Offender Name: JULIO CESAR GARZA
DOB: Sat, 6 Oct 1990
Height: 5 Feet 6 Inches
Weight: 145
Sex: M
Location: UTAH STATE PRISON
Housing Facility: UINTA
Parole Date: N/A
Aliases:
CHUCO
CHUCO
JULIO CESAR GARZA

Monsters Among Us: Andres Fernandez killed Louis “LuLu” Barbati, one of the owners of iconic L&B Spumoni Gardens pizzeria; Sentenced to 24 years to life in prison


Louis W. Barbati

Louis W. Barbati obituary
Find-A-Grave: Louis W. Barbati
Suspect in Custody in Deadly Shooting of Famed Brooklyn Pizzeria Owner: Official
Owner of iconic Brooklyn pizza joint gunned down in hit job
Funeral For L&B Spumoni Gardens Co-Owner Louis Barbati To Be Held Tuesday
Trial on the Murder of a Brooklyn Pizzeria Legend Begins This Week
Man Guilty of Murder in Ambush of Famed Brooklyn Pizzeria Owner
Long Island man found guilty in murder of L&B Spumoni Gardens owner
Man convicted in slaying of L&B Spumoni Gardens co-owner Louis Barbati
Widow of murdered Brooklyn pizza joint owner breaks down in court
Long Island man sentenced in shooting death of beloved NYC restaurant owner
Man Who Murdered Beloved Brooklyn Pizzeria Legend Showed ‘No Remorse’ In Court
LI man sentenced in killing of L&B Spumoni Gardens owner
Killer of L&B Spumoni Gardens owner sentenced to 24 years to life
L&B Spumoni Gardens
Wikipedia: L&B Spumoni Gardens

Movies/Documentaries
New York Homicide: Pizza Man Murdered
Devoured: A Slice of the Pie
America’s Test Kitchen: Dinner in Italy

INMATE INFORMATION

Identifying and Location Information
As of 03/07/22
DIN (Department Identification Number) 20A1692
Inmate Name FERNANDEZ, ANDRES
Sex MALE
Date of Birth 08/19/1975
Race / Ethnicity WHITE
Custody Status IN CUSTODY
Housing / Releasing Facility CLINTON
Date Received (Original) 11/17/2020
Date Received (Current) 11/17/2020
Admission Type NEW COMMITMENT
County of Commitment KINGS
Latest Release Date / Type (Released Inmates Only)

Crimes of Conviction
Crime MURDER 2ND
Class A1

Crime CRIM POSS WEAP 2ND
Class C

Sentence Terms and Release Dates
Under certain circumstances, an inmate may be released prior to serving his or her minimum term and before the earliest release date shown for the inmate.
As of 03/07/22
Aggregate Minimum Sentence 0024 Years, 00 Months, 00 Days
Aggregate Maximum Sentence LIFE Years, 99 Months, 99 Days
Earliest Release Date 11/02/2040
Earliest Release Type PAROLE ELIGIBILITY DATE
Parole Hearing Date 07/2040
Parole Hearing Type INITIAL RELEASE APPEARANCE
Parole Eligibility Date 11/02/2040
Conditional Release Date NONE
Maximum Expiration Date LIFE
Maximum Expiration Date for Parole Supervision
Post Release Supervision Maximum Expiration Date
Parole Board Discharge Date

%d bloggers like this: