• This Day in Crime History

    January 16: 1936: Serial Killer Hamilton Howard “Albert” Fish was executed in the electric chair in Sing Sing Prison. He was responsible for at least 5 murders, including 10-year-old Grace Budd whose murder he was sentenced to death for.

  • Email me!

  • My Twitter Page

  • Goodreads

  • Social Media

  • Donate

  • Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

    Join 5,783 other followers

  • How to unsubscribe from my blog

    Unfollowing and Unsubscribing username account: 1. click the "unsubscribe" link on the emails of the posts received at the very bottom of the emails. 2. go here >!/read/edit/ locate and click the "x" next to any blog there to unfollow it and no longer receive posts in the Reader or by email. 3. go to the blog in question and click the unfollow/follow link on your Admin bar. If you do not have a username account then 1. applies. 1. click the "unsubscribe" link on the emails of the posts received at the very bottom of the emails.
  • Subscribe to my blog via email

  • Comment Policy

    Please remember when leaving a comment on my blog that all comments are subject to the blog owners discretion. I do believe in freedom of speech, however, that right is not absolute. Here are the rules: 1 - Please remember the victim(s) first and foremost. Do not come here to comment only on the offender(s). My blog focuses on the victim(s). Do not glorify the killer(s). No negative comments about the victim. NO VICTIM BLAMING. 2 - I will not tolerate hate filled speech, vulgar or derogatory remarks about a victim. I will remove comments that go against this. I will not remove comments just because they do not match my beliefs, in fact, I welcome them! However, that being said, I will remove those that I find offensive, argumentative just for the sake of starting an argument that does not add to the post, hate-filled speech, etc. 3-No comments in ALL CAPS, or CoMeNtS. They are rude and difficult to read. I have had many complaints about it so no more. 4-Comments must be in English only and easy to read (meaning no text language, shortening words, etc.). Have respect for those who don't do text messaging or other lingo. 5 - ALL COMMENTS LEFT BY COMMENTORS ARE THEIR OWN AND THEIR OPINIONS. THEY DO NOT CONSTITUTE FACTS. NOR IS THE BLOG OWNER RESPONSIBLE FOR ANYONE'S OPINIONS OR FEELINGS. STATEMENTS MADE AS COMMENTS ARE OPINIONS, GIVEN FREELY BY THE COMMENTORS. If you have a question or problem with this, please feel free to email me (there is a link to my email above).
  • Advertisements

Kids That Kill: Wendy Gardner & James Evans kill Elizabeth “Betty” Gardner, Wendy’s grandmother


Betty Gardner
Betty Gardner

Find-A-Grave: Elizabeth Betty Gardner
State police say Saugerties teens killed grandmother
Girl’s plans for revenge led to grandmother’s murder
‘Just Do It’: Last Word Became Last Rites for Doomed Grandmother
Girl, 15, Guilty in Her Grandmother’s Killing
Woman convicted of murder of grandmother as 13-year-old is released from prison on parole
Killer at 13, parole try not far off
Parole Board viewed Evans as ‘danger … to society’

Kill Grandma for Me

Killer Kids: Family Killers
Deadly Women: Mean Teens

Gweneviere Wendy Gardner – convicted; sentenced to almost 8 years in prison (paroled 2004)
James Evans – convicted; sentenced to 9 years to life in prison (Will be paroled in January 2014, but this is unconfirmed)


21 Responses

  1. James Evans has been moved from one prison to another. As of 2013 he IS still in custody and trying to get paroled, as he attempts every 2 years. Those closest to him say he hasn’t changed much. Has a conduct disorder, still obsessed with his past, he justifies taking a life, and they say it would be best for everyone if he never gets released.

  2. Hmm…as someone that is very close to him and his family I would disagree with the statement that he hasn’t changed much. In fact, I can’t think of anyone close to him that would say that. Who exactly is your informant, or did you make that up? You are also incorrect about the parole. He was granted parole in November and will be released in January 2014. Sorry to bust that bubble as well. Wait…not really. I’m quite happy for him :). You would also be incorrect to imply that his being moved from prison to prison is because of conduct. It happens for a variety of reasons. I am curious why you keep such a close eye on him. Who exactly are you to be smearing him anyway? I’m going to guess Wendy’s lover. Am I hot or cold?

    • Lovelylady,

      I am not certain as to who you are talking to. I am the blog owner, and I post on many, many cases like this. I am not out to smear anyone, and have no idea who Wendy’s lover is, nor do I care. I care about the victim, Elizabeth Gardner, who you never even bothered to mention. I have no “informant” and I never said anything about whether anyone has changed or not. If you got that from one of the links, then it is that place you need to ask about it. Grow up. No one has said anything horrible about either killer. But I, the blog owner, am upset that you did not even bother to mention Elizabeth and she is the one that needs to be remembered here. My focus is on the victim. If you can’t talk about her and a memory of her, then don’t bother.

      • I understand and apologize for any insensativity or disrespect towards the gardner family that may have come with my post. My response was actually directed at the previous comment/poster and not for you or the actual blog. I understand if you decide to take it down as it is not in the appropriate place for that type of conversation but it would probably be only fair to remove the previous poster’s comment (by dagnabbit) as well considering Betty is not the focus of that discussion (by dagnabbit) and it is insulting to me and to others.

    • He should stay locked up for killing that poor defenceless old lady

  3. Just watched the story about the Betty Gardner murder on Unusual Suspects on ID channel. How sad. Was that animal released this month? I doubt James will ever feel sorry for what he done.

  4. Just watched the story myself on ID channel in Scotland. If he was black he would never have been released in the US. But I beleive that people can change and he was very young.

  5. He was released and I fear he had a relationship with someone close to me. I hope she does not end up like Mrs. Gardner. My prayers to all involved

    • “Julie”, I’m sure if you expressed your concern to Amanda directly she would tell you your fears are unnecessary. If you spend any time around the two of them your opinion might be different as you would see how unbelievably good he is to her and how much they love each other. It is a sharp contrast to the dangerous and immensely unhealthy relationship that brewed between him and Wendy and which led to his involvement in Betty’s death.

  6. Justice was served. Both James and Wendy completed their sentence. In the end, James served 19 years. He was sentenced as a minor but this is nearly the time he would have received if sentenced as as adult because of parole rejections (for reasons that the Supreme Court later determined were unjust). Wendy served only 10 years.
    James was evaluated on 4 separate occasions by psychiatrists prior to his release, as well as once after, to ensure he was not mentally ill (including sociopathic) and for risk assessment. He was found to be a very low risk for recidivism (relapse into criminal behavior) and they determined he is not suffering from any mental illness and therefore deemed him fit for release into society.
    Now he is living his life happily and as fully and peacefully as he can with his fiancé, the love of his life. His family and friends comprise the strongest support system he could have hoped for.
    James was young when this horrific event transpired. Though he wishes, more than anything, he could reverse his actions that resulted in Betty’s death, it is not humanly possible. Still, he has matured considerably over 20 years’ time. James is exceptionally kind, intelligent and a decent person that should not be hated or feared because of what happened 20 years ago. He has paid and continues to pay the price for that mistake.

    • Lovelylady,

      While that is all good, what about Betty Gardner? You spoke not one word about her and my blog focuses on the victim. I am glad he is remorseful, so I am sure he has told Betty’s family that. I hope he does volunteer work with victims to really show that work. If he is truly remorseful, he will not hide from what he did, but rather, he will share it with others.

      • As for Betty, may she rest in peace. Her life was cut short and she deserved a more time on this earth. She deserved to have more time with her family and they deserved to not have to go through what went through with her loss and the murder trials. There isn’t anything I or anyone else can say to make it better. Might I add, just because I know and love one of the perpetrators does not make my condolences any less sincere.
        I have no updates on Betty and I cannot contribute any information to what you have posted here about her specifically.
        You include information regarding the defendants, do you not? A brief statement of what happened to them and links to articles about them and what happened to them. I am only adding to your information what I know about one of the them, specifically James. He, as a direct order of the parole board, cannot have any contact with the victim’s family and that includes third-party contact. So a direct apology would be out of the question. I am sure the Gardner family would have it no other way.
        It is equally as tragic that two kids made the decision to end her life, which resulted in them losing a significant period of their lives. They deprived themselves of a normal adulthood among other things in choosing to do so. I am not saying you should pity them but I would hope you would agree it is a shame. Are they not worth discussing? Other people here think so.
        It’s interesting that of the 6 people that commented on this post, none of them (myself included) had anything to say about Betty. However, you chose to single me out. Why is that? If you don’t want my opinion up here with everyone else’s, just delete it. Stop trying to browbeat me over it.

  7. Sorry, but we are talking about a guy who got his rocks off by torturing cats, before he moved on to killing an old lady….I doubt very much that he’s learned any lessons,or changed much. Lock up your harmless pets and keep an eye on your helpless family members if you live near this coward. I’m sure we haven’t heard the last of him.

    • Except that the part of the book (or that ONE Daily Freeman article) where you read he tortured cats was inaccurate. It was presented in court only during Wendy’s trial as “gossip” in the neighborhood and wasn’t presented as fact to the court. Your opinion of his character means nothing. His continued compliance with Parole conditions is only one example support the FACT that he has. But that’s none of your business anyhow. I’m doubtful you live your life in fear of him and there’s no reason for anyone else.

      • ^that was intended to be the reply to “k” the previous poster. Not the entire thread, obviously.

  8. Wendy and James should still be locked up as far as im concerned. I do not feel safe living in Ulster County with those two murderers on the loose. Its disgusting how the justice system has failed us all. May Betty Gardner rest in peace. James Evans, you are an animal. Wendy, you are a h**. You both will get what yall deserve.

  9. I’m very interested to see an update about Wendy Gardner and James Evans. It is 2017, the only updates I see are from 2004.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: