Deadly Duo: John & Lela Whiteley killed Henry R. Caneva during a home invasion; Both convicted of his murder, sentenced to prison*


Henry and Jan

Lela Whiteley is Jan Scott’s stepdaughter from her previous marriage. This happened because Lela felt like if Jan and Henry were gone, she would get the house. She also felt like Jan’s jewelry should go to her, since her father bought the jewelry. She was incorrect on both issues.

Find-A-Grave: Henry R. Caneva
Blurred memory of attack haunts survivor (part 1)
Memory of attack haunts survivor
Murder suspects Lela and John Whiteley have a pattern of violence – against each other
Sarasota couple won’t face death penalty (part 1)
Suspects in slaying have violent history (part 2)
Murder trial begins Monday
Woman pleads no contest
Murder trial begins Monday

Movies/Documentaries
Unusual Suspects: Left for Dead
In Ice Cold Blood: Widowed Witness

INMATE INFORMATION

DC Number: S00852
Name: WHITELEY, JOHN J
Race: WHITE
Sex: MALE
Hair Color: BROWN
Eye Color: HAZEL
Height: 6’03”
Weight: 213 lbs.
Birth Date: 09/27/1959
Initial Receipt Date: 05/19/2000
Release Date: 11/19/2015

Stated Residence Upon Release:
5610 NEW YORK AVENUE
SARASOTA,FL 3423134231

Aliases:
JOHN J WHITELEY
JOHN JOSEPH WHITELEY
JOHN JR WHITELEY

INMATE INFORMATION

DC Number: S07690
Name: WHITELEY, LELA A
Race: WHITE
Sex: FEMALE
Hair Color: RED OR AUBURN
Eye Color: HAZEL
Height: 5’05”
Weight: 142 lbs.
Birth Date: 08/01/1958
Initial Receipt Date: 05/09/2000
Supervision Begin Date: 12/29/2015
Current Location: SARASOTA
Current Status: ACTIVE
Supervision Type: PROBATION FELONY
Scheduled Termination Date: 12/28/2025

Current Verified PERMANENT Address:
5769 NEW YORK AVE
SARASOTA, FL 34231

Aliases:
LELA ANN HODGES
LELA ANN PLATT JERKINS
LELA ANN SCOTT
LELA WHITELEY
LELA A WHITELEY
LELA ANN WHITELEY HODGES

13 Responses

  1. the way i see it, these people should have gotten LIFE!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Jean, who was married to Henry, stole the house that was this woman’s father’s…and even the her mother’s rings! Jean needs to be in jail, too! Thief! Some con old hag stealing from the man’s kids!! WRONG!

    Like

    • First fact 1: she was not married to Henry. Fact 2: In her husband’s will he left the house & his entire estate to her. So she didn’t steal the house. Fact 3: If the rings were so important to Lela, then why didn’t she talk to her stepmom about it seeing as they stayed close for years after her father died? For you to call this woman a thief for staying in a home that was rightfully hers, is wrong. They deserve a lot more then the sentence they got.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Not that they should have killed her, but the wife (jan/jean) did a horrible thing to keep the daughter’s rings that belonged to her mother from her! The wife who lived was very very wrong to begin with! They house shouldn’t even be hers…she was asking for hatred at the least by stealing family heirlooms!

    Like

    • Interesting – that’s an ignorant way of looking at it. The Law in Sarasota (or rather Florida) clearly stipulates that the children will receive part of the estate. Lela was entitled by legal means to either contest or sue for her rightful benefits. So…I suppose she didn’t get the rings.

      Like

    • Her rings! Of course they should have killed her and then killed her again! I say you steal a ring you should be killed by a mob! How dare. She?

      Liked by 1 person

  4. Interesting…this was my brother in law’s father that was STRANGLED AND CARVED up. Jan was left for dead, but luckily survived. YOU, obviously, are a sick friend of these losers and/or their birth mother. Tyana said it correctly, you are ignorant. I have far more colorful adjectives to describe you, but since you ARE ignorant, you will only come back with your lame comments so I won’t waste my time. My family will be at either of these MURDERERS parole hearings, should they come up, and will try to keep them in until THEY die which is what they deserve.

    Like

    • When you find out when their parole hearings are, can you post that information here? Then I can get people to send in letters to oppose their paroles and keep them in prison for life. Thanks!

      Liked by 1 person

    • They are out.. Living within minutes of where everything took place. Just evil presence with them two out in the public a threat to society. Im sure they won’t be able to stay out of the troubling spotlight. Set the alarms & load the guns. Who knows what these people are thinking.

      Like

  5. They were released on different dates in 2015. Not justice by a long shot.

    Like

  6. Selfish jealousy raged attack. Still to this day living right next where they did such a Selfish hanish crime. Set the alarms and load the guns. They live amongst us. Who knows what these people are thinking now n days that they are out.

    Like

  7. This was just on A&E. Murder on Mirror Lake S13.E6
    I’ve never heard of this case until city confidential. I’m glad Jan lived, but these 2 did not get the punishment they deserved! Lela had a lot of falling outs with her father and I think this is the reason everything was left to Jan. And not to be mean to Henry, but his kids seemed to be greedy.

    Like

    • You can’t profit from your crime lady! Now you are spending the rest of your life in prison, and your mothers home and jewelry go to her next of kin but it won’t be you! What a selfish, narcissist you are!

      Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.